KY Virtual Library Advisory Committee Minutes

1:00 p.m., August 25, 2006

Frankfort, KY

 

Present: Mike Binder, Barbara Caron, Anne Chase, Fannie Cox, Diane Culbertson, Charlene Davis [for Jim Nelson], Carol Diedrichs, Paul Fuller [for Shelley Burgett], Holly Hedden, Chela Kaplan, Al Lind, Norma Northern, Elsie Pritchard, Hannelore Rader,  Enid Wohlstein

 

Absent:  Shelley Burgett , Norma Northern, Stuart Johnston, Donna Travillian

 

1. Selection of VLAC Officers (Wohlstein)

 

Membership rotation for Chair.  Enid distributed a document with a proposed roster and rotation.  VLAC approved the roster.  Holly Hedden will discuss the VLUG position in the rotation with the VLUG officers.

 

2. News from VLAC Members

 

Members shared news and events.

 

3. News from KYVU (Lind)

 

Al discussed a draft of the strategic plan for KYVU entitled “Supporting Kentucky’s eLearning Ecosystem” which was distributed to all VLAC members.  The draft was presented to DLAC on 8/22.  CPE will be presented with the plan on 9/17 and after approval, the plan will translate to a budget and work plan.

 

NCHE conducted an environmental scan of entities like KYVU.  A total of 54 were surveyed.  As a participant, we will be able to view the data. 

 

KEN has been allotted $30 million for a technology infrastructure upgrade and other projects.  An Applications Committee has been created to assess needs of K12 and postsecondary and will report back to the Executive Committee for KEN. 

 

4. News from KYVL (Wohlstein)

 

Enid provided updates on the RFPs for the research databases and courier.  Finance and Administration had granted a one-time extension to the contracts and all vendors [EBSCO, H.W. Wilson, Proquest, Grolier, and Lanter] agreed to the extension.  All contracts will expire 30 June 2007. 

 

The Senior Reference Librarian position was posted for applications and a search committee is reviewing the resumes. 

 

Enid will attend a symposium in September on courier services.  “Moving Mountains:  A Symposium Exploring Library Courier Services” will take place 14 & 15 September in Denver.

 

FYI that 15 September is US Constitution Day on Internet 2 and Frankfort Independent will be participating.

 

The Breaking Down Barriers Conference will be October 30 and 31st.  The proposal deadline is 8 September.  Vendors are still being solicited. 

 

Enid distributed a copy of the resolution to honor Jim Nelson, upon his retirement as Commissioner of Libraries/State Librarian.  The resolution had previously been approved by VLAC via email.

 

A new charge for the Portal Workgroup was presented.  The Portal Workgroup shall be newly charged with the following:  To advise the Kentucky Virtual Library in the creation and support of the KYVL MetaLib/SFX Consortium to ensure effective access for users and library staff.

 

Enid presented a proposed rotation for VLAC chairs, including the roster of past chairs which was accepted by VLAC. 

 

5. ILS Subcommittee report (Pritchard)

 

Elsie presented the recommendations from the ILS Task Force.  See attached.

 

Elsie also distributed the final results combined from the two surveys conducted. 

 

A motion was made to accept the recommendations and dismiss the ILS Task Force.  VLAC thanks them for their service.

 

 

6. Council of Chief Academic Officers (CCAO) meeting and KYVL (Wohlstein)

 

The Council of Chief Academic Officers of the state-supported postsecondary education institutions reviews academic policy issues and provides advice and consultation to the Council staff on academic initiatives.  Membership is comprised of the CAO's from the eight public universities and colleges and KCTCS.  At the last CCAO meeting, a draft of a memo to Jim Applegate from the CCAO was discussed.  The memo was presented on behalf of SAALCK. 

CCAO did not approve or endorse the memo in its entirety. 

 

Key points presented in the memo:

A.      Funds for KYVL initiatives, such as a new or enhanced ILS, should be separated from technology funds.  Recommend a “library technology” line item for academic libraries.

B.      Continued support and expansion of databases provided through KYVL contracts is essential to Kentucky’s libraries and P-16 students.  Usage statistics are necessary to SAALCK in order to conduct analysis of resources specific to universities.

C.      The Endeavor Voyager Integrated Library System as it is now does not meet the needs of users and a replacement or upgrade must be pursued.

D.      SAALCK is forming two study groups, one for ILS investigation (to be conducted in cooperationwith KYVL) and the second for Electronic Resource Management.

Enid and Al answered questions related to funding, support and commitment to the two projects.  The CCAO asked for further information on both subjects, including financial benefit and impact, and did not endorse the memo as it was written.

 

7. SREB’s SCORE Initiative (Wohlstein)

 

Enid relayed conversations at DLST [Distance Learning Steering Team] regarding the SREB SCORE project for a shared learning object repository.  Enid had recommended to DLST that a joint committee of DLST and VLAC-appointed representatives be assigned to SCORE.  KVHS/KDE has joined at the middle level.  Louisiana has offered to host the registry.  The Florida Orange Grove repository includes some independent institutions.  A few key points:  permissions and sharing would be determined by the institutions, and some may want digital repositories for digital objects like images.  SCORE is learning objects only and would be used to build courses.

 

As this initiative moves forward, Enid will keep VLAC informed and ask for representation to serve on the planning committee and any subcommittees formed.

8.      Next Meeting. 

October 27 was selected.

 

9.      Meeting adjourned. 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Kentucky Virtual Library -- KYVL

 

Virtual Library Advisory Committee

 

Resolution to Honor James A. (Jim) Nelson

 

Whereas  James A. (Jim) Nelson is completing his tenure as State Librarian and Commissioner of the Kentucky Department for Libraries and Archives  (KDLA) having served since 1980, the longest serving state librarian for Kentucky and the second longest serving in the nation and

 

Whereas  Under the direction of Jim Nelson, KDLA has grown and served as the state agency responsible for statewide library development as well as the management and preservation of public records in Kentucky.  KDLA has provided grants, technical assistance and direct services to libraries, archival repositories and public agencies throughout the Commonwealth.  KDLA also offers reference, research and specialized information services from Frankfort and

 

Whereas    In 1997, the Council on Postsecondary Education (CPE) Chair Leonard Hardin named a Distance Learning Advisory Committee (DLAC) to advise the CPE on Commonwealth Virtual University (CVU) development. Jim Nelson, Commissioner and State Librarian, was appointed to the DLAC and              

 

Whereas   In 1998, DLAC Chair Lee Todd appointed the CVU Work Group on CVL which served as the CVL Steering Committee.  Jim Nelson was appointed to be the Chair. The Steering Committee was composed of representatives from all types of libraries and

 

Whereas   In November of 1999, KCVL was officially launched with a reception at the Kentucky History Center.  Jim Nelson continued to serve as chair and

 

Whereas  In August of 2000, KCVL changed to the Kentucky Virtual Library (KYVL) and has become one of the finest virtual libraries anywhere becoming a model for many other states and Jim Nelson has remained a major force in the inception and implementation  and success of KYVL and

Whereas   With the financial support of KDLA and the professional support of Jim Nelson, KYVL has grown and prospered serving its mission which states:  All Kentuckians will have equitable access to quality library and information resources and qualified, well-trained staff to support the Kentucky Virtual University as well as meet broader needs for learning, working and living and

Therefore for this and his many other achievements while serving with the Kentucky Department of Libraries and Archives, Jim Nelson is honored with sincere appreciation and gratitude for his many contributions to the Kentucky Virtual Library by this Virtual Library Advisory committee.

Adopted by the Membership of the Kentucky Virtual Library (KYVL) Advisory Committee (VLAC) on August 25, 2006.

 

______________________________________

Enid G. Wohlstein, Director, Kentucky Virtual Library


Virtual Library Advisory Committee

 

Past Chairs and Proposed Roster

 

Jim Nelson - State Librarian

1st Chair through May 2001

Rep:  KDLA

 

Hannelore Rader – Dean of Libraries,

University of Louisville

May 2001 through July 2003

Rep:  Research institutions

 

Arne Almquist –  Associate Provost for Library Services,

Northern Kentucky University

July 2003 through August 2004

Rep:  Comprehensive institutions

 

Diane Culbertson – KSMA

August 2004 through June 2005

Rep:  KSMA

 

Lisa Rice – Director,

Bowling Green Public Library

June 2005 through June 2006

Rep:  PLA

 

Shelley Burgett -  Director of Library Services,

Somerset Community College

2006 to 2007

Rep:  KCTCS

 

KDE

 

VLUG

 

AIKCU

 

Special Libraries

 

AE


 

Voting Members per Bylaws

 

Research Institutions – 2 reps - UK, UofL

 

Comprehensive Institutions – 2 reps - (Eastern Kentucky University, Kentucky State University, Morehead State University, Murray State University, Northern Kentucky University, and Western Kentucky University)

 

KCTCS – 1 rep

 

AIKCU – 1 rep

 

KDE – 1 rep

 

KSMA – 1 rep

 

KDLA – 1 rep

 

Public Library Association of KLA – 1 rep

 

Special Libraries – 1 rep

 

Adult Education – 1 rep

 

VLUG – 1 rep

 

 

 


M E M O R A N D U M

 

TO:                  VLAC

 

FROM:            ILS Task Force

 

                        Perry Bratcher (Northern Kentucky University)

Charlene Davis (KDLA)

John Detweiler (KDLA)

Margaret Foote (Eastern Kentucky University)

Paul Fuller (KCTCS)

Tari Keller (University of Kentucky)

Mark Paul (University of Louisville)

Elsie Pritchard (Morehead State U.), Chair

Enid Wohlstein (KYVL)

 

DATE:                        August 1, 2006

 

RE:                  Task Force Recommendations

 

The ILS Task Force was appointed in fall 2005 to examine the current server configuration supporting the KYVL Consortium’s installation of the Voyager ILS, and to begin discussions in preparation for the state’s adoption of a new integrated system.  The Task Force met regularly, conducted a survey of other consortia, and would like to recommend these principles for server operation:

 

1.                        Server sites should provide regular cost accounting.

 

2.                        The consortium should be prepared to pay a fair market rate for server operation.

 

3.                        Centralized funding should be provided for server operation.

 

4.                        The consortium should issue an RFI to gather information about the potential cost savings of moving to a single server site and to gather information about a variety of service providers.

 

The ILS Task Force also strongly recommends that the next ILS should be run on the native platform.  Furthermore, if a server upgrade is necessary while the consortium is still running the Voyager system, the Task Force recommends that the consortium consider migrating Voyager to the native platform as part of the upgrade.

 

 



Consortium Survey Summary: Final

 

ILS Task Force of the Virtual Library Advisory Council

 

Governance

1.       What is the nature of the relationship between the consortium's hub-site host institution(s) and the client institutions/libraries whose databases are housed on the servers?

 

Wide variety of responses

 

2. Was the consortium relationship mandated by some authority or agency outside of your institution?

 

No mandates reported

 

3. Is the relationship between the institutions, server host(s) and network provider governed by a written agreement?


Yes – 3

No – 1

 

4. What are the funding sources for your consortium?

 

State & institutions – 3

State & institutions plus other sources – 1

 

Library Applications

 

5. What integrated library system does your consortium use?

 

Voyager – 12

Aleph (ExLibris) -2

Sirsi – 1

Innovative Interfaces 2


6. Does the server site run any other library software— metasearch, link resolver, ILL, ERMS, or other—for the consortium?

 

Yes, multiple – 8

Yes, universal borrower – 1

No - 4

 

Server Configuration, Hardware, Operating System

 

7. Does the ILS run on a server(s) that is shared by the institutions or do they have independent servers? If independent, why was this implementation chosen?

 

Shared – 3

Shared & independent - 3

 

8. Where are the servers located?

 

Member institution – 11 (Most mention the institution’s computing center.)

Near consortium headquarters or another central location -4

Commercial server farm - 1

 

 

9. How many institutions use each server?

 

Average: 12

Low: 1

High: 70 (MnPALS)

 

10. At the server site(s), how many servers are used to run the ILS? Are all components of the production system

on one server or are application, database and/or web server on different servers?

 

Application server-web server – 7

Single server – 5

Other - 4

 

11. What is the hardware and operating system platform for your ILS server(s)?

 

Sun – 12

IBM – 3

 

12. Has your consortium always been organized the same way with regard to hub sites? If there was a significant

change such as a move from multiple hub sites to a single hub site, please describe the change and the reasons

for making it. Why was the original implementation chosen and what changed to make it no longer preferable?

 

Yes – 4

 

13. Is the hardware and operating system platform the same as the vendor’s development platform? If not, what is

the vendor’s development platform?

 

Yes – 4

No - 1


14. Do you have a test server?

 

Yes - 5

 

15. How would you handle disaster recovery?

 

Server at another site is available just in case – 1

Multiple server sites – 1

Written plan – 2

 

Staff, Service, Network

 

16. What is the staff size in FTE dedicated to supporting the ILS?

 

Average – about 7 per consortium, but some include much more than running the ILS


17. Who is ultimately responsible for network problems occurring between hub-site and institution?

 

Varies widely


18. What service issues if any have been raised by client institutions and how are they handled?

 

Varies; no big problems reported


19. How are network stability and speed?

 

No major problems reported.


20. In what ways does your consortium operating structure benefit your institution? Do you see any disadvantages to your consortium operating structure?

 

Advantages: saves money by sharing equipment and staff; aids in sharing ideas and information; higher

level of service for all, especially for smaller libraries; more flexible work assignments; aids in sharing

collections; 24-hour support; don’t have to work around local IT priorities.

 

Disadvantages: harder to schedule upgrades; less customization; centralized budgeting more affected by

cuts.